WHO global research priorities for traditional, complementary, and integrative (TCI) medicine: an international consensus and comparisons with LLMs

dc.contributor.authorAhn S.
dc.contributor.authorZhou J.
dc.contributor.authorJiang D.
dc.contributor.authorKerr S.
dc.contributor.authorZhu Y.
dc.contributor.authorSong P.
dc.contributor.authorRudan I.
dc.contributor.authorHammerschlag R.
dc.contributor.authorSkoetz N.
dc.contributor.authorSavrikar S.
dc.contributor.authorFong H.H.S.
dc.contributor.authorShaoping L.
dc.contributor.authorAkarasereenont P.
dc.contributor.authorCramer H.
dc.contributor.authorSalih S.J.
dc.contributor.authorWang M.
dc.contributor.authorSmith C.
dc.contributor.authorMasiero S.
dc.contributor.authorJong M.
dc.contributor.authorDevarajan E.
dc.contributor.authorHughes J.
dc.contributor.authorTsang W.
dc.contributor.authorChong L.F.
dc.contributor.authorXin C.
dc.contributor.authorMing W.C.
dc.contributor.authorLi Z.
dc.contributor.authorQibiao W.
dc.contributor.authorTing L.
dc.contributor.authorLu Y.
dc.contributor.authorStone J.A.M.
dc.contributor.authorKessler C.
dc.contributor.authorNg J.
dc.contributor.authorSajdyk T.J.
dc.contributor.authorKunle O.
dc.contributor.authorHanser S.B.
dc.contributor.authorWiesner J.
dc.contributor.authorCatabay A.
dc.contributor.authorElisabetsky E.
dc.contributor.authorBarth J.
dc.contributor.authorShefer E.
dc.contributor.authorSoon G.C.
dc.contributor.authorSanogo R.
dc.contributor.authorPark S.
dc.contributor.authorKhan I.A.
dc.contributor.authorSklaviadis T.
dc.contributor.authorWitt C.
dc.contributor.authorBian Z.
dc.contributor.authorLee S.
dc.contributor.authorXue C.
dc.contributor.authorSkaltsa E.
dc.contributor.authorBensoussan A.
dc.contributor.authorDuez P.
dc.contributor.authorNielsen A.
dc.contributor.authorLiu J.
dc.contributor.authorSastry J.L.
dc.contributor.authorYeh G.
dc.contributor.authordas Gracas Lins M.
dc.contributor.authorVillar M.
dc.contributor.authorChe C.T.
dc.contributor.authorMo H.
dc.contributor.correspondenceAhn S.
dc.contributor.otherMahidol University
dc.date.accessioned2025-11-22T18:22:27Z
dc.date.available2025-11-22T18:22:27Z
dc.date.issued2025-01-01
dc.description.abstractBackground Traditional, complementary, and integrative (TCI) medicine is an essential component of health systems worldwide, especially in low- and middle-income countries. Despite its widespread use, existing research on the safety, efficacy, and integration of TCI medicine within conventional healthcare systems is fragmented. This fragmentation highlights the urgent need for a clearly defined global research agenda to guide future studies, secure funding, and inform governance in this field. Methods The Traditional, Complementary, and Integrative Medicine Unit at the World Health Organization Headquarters in Geneva, Switzerland coordinated an international research priority-setting exercise using the Child Health and Nutrition Research Initiative (CHNRI) method between June and December 2023. We invited a purposive sample of 120 experts from established academic networks to participate; 53 experts (44.16% response rate) contributed, and 34 of them scored 157 unique research ideas according to five CHNRI criteria: feasibility, effectiveness, deliverability, equity, and potential for disease burden reduction. Additionally, we performed a comparative analysis by generating research priorities using large language models (LLMs), including ChatGPT-4o, Claude 3.5, and Grok 3, and these outputs were compared with the expert-derived priorities. Results Top-ranked research priorities focused on chronic disease management (e.g. diabetes, dyslipidemia), geriatric safety (e.g. herb-drug interactions), mental health (e.g. resilience and mood disorders), and integration of TCI into health systems. Priorities varied by income setting. Comparison with LLM-generated lists showed thematic overlap in efficacy and safety but divergence in focus, with LLMs emphasising research capacity, policy, and systems-level priorities. Conclusions We established a global, expert-informed research agenda to guide the future direction of TCI medicine and ensure alignment with public health needs. The comparison with LLMs highlights the complementary potential of artificial intelligence in research governance and agenda-setting.
dc.identifier.citationJournal of Global Health Vol.15 (2025)
dc.identifier.doi10.7189/jogh.15.04336
dc.identifier.eissn20472986
dc.identifier.issn20472978
dc.identifier.pmid41232122
dc.identifier.scopus2-s2.0-105021764577
dc.identifier.urihttps://repository.li.mahidol.ac.th/handle/123456789/113166
dc.rights.holderSCOPUS
dc.subjectMedicine
dc.titleWHO global research priorities for traditional, complementary, and integrative (TCI) medicine: an international consensus and comparisons with LLMs
dc.typeArticle
mu.datasource.scopushttps://www.scopus.com/inward/record.uri?partnerID=HzOxMe3b&scp=105021764577&origin=inward
oaire.citation.titleJournal of Global Health
oaire.citation.volume15
oairecerif.author.affiliationZhejiang University
oairecerif.author.affiliationUniversità degli Studi di Padova
oairecerif.author.affiliationUniversity of Illinois at Chicago
oairecerif.author.affiliationIcahn School of Medicine at Mount Sinai
oairecerif.author.affiliationEberhard Karls Universität Tübingen
oairecerif.author.affiliationNational and Kapodistrian University of Athens
oairecerif.author.affiliationUniversiteit Leiden
oairecerif.author.affiliationAristotle University of Thessaloniki
oairecerif.author.affiliationUniversidade Federal do Rio Grande do Sul
oairecerif.author.affiliationUniversity of Oxford Medical Sciences Division
oairecerif.author.affiliationUniversidade Federal de Minas Gerais
oairecerif.author.affiliationRMIT University
oairecerif.author.affiliationMahidol University
oairecerif.author.affiliationKyung Hee University
oairecerif.author.affiliationUniversitatsSpital Zurich
oairecerif.author.affiliationWestern Sydney University
oairecerif.author.affiliationUiT Norges Arktiske Universitet
oairecerif.author.affiliationMinistry of Health of Russian Federation
oairecerif.author.affiliationUniversity of Macau
oairecerif.author.affiliationUniklinik Köln
oairecerif.author.affiliationHong Kong Baptist University
oairecerif.author.affiliationUniversity College London Hospitals NHS Foundation Trust
oairecerif.author.affiliationBeijing University of Chinese Medicine
oairecerif.author.affiliationEdinburgh Medical School
oairecerif.author.affiliationHangzhou Normal University
oairecerif.author.affiliationMacau University of Science and Technology
oairecerif.author.affiliationUniversité de Mons
oairecerif.author.affiliationKementerian Kesihatan Malaysia
oairecerif.author.affiliationHong Kong Metropolitan University
oairecerif.author.affiliationUniversity of Mississippi School of Pharmacy
oairecerif.author.affiliationVivantes Netzwerk für Gesundheit
oairecerif.author.affiliationZhejiang University School of Public Health
oairecerif.author.affiliationGreen Templeton College
oairecerif.author.affiliationUniversité des Sciences, des Techniques et des Technologies de Bamako
oairecerif.author.affiliationUniversity of Al-Ameed
oairecerif.author.affiliationNational Institute for Pharmaceutical Research and Development, Nigeria
oairecerif.author.affiliationDe La Salle Medical and Health Sciences Institute
oairecerif.author.affiliationBerklee College of Music
oairecerif.author.affiliationIndiana University
oairecerif.author.affiliationNational Institute of Food and Drug Safety Evaluation
oairecerif.author.affiliationNational Institute for Korean Medicine Development
oairecerif.author.affiliationMorarji Desai National Institute of Yoga
oairecerif.author.affiliationHealth Bureau of Macau
oairecerif.author.affiliationFederal Institute for Drugs and Medical Devices
oairecerif.author.affiliationUniversity Hospital
oairecerif.author.affiliationBeth Israel Lahey Health
oairecerif.author.affiliationPharmacopeia Commission of India
oairecerif.author.affiliationSocial Health Insurance of Peru
oairecerif.author.affiliationNova Institute
oairecerif.author.affiliationHealth Bureau
oairecerif.author.affiliationNational Medicinal Plant Board

Files

Collections