Comparison of Patient Health Questionnaire-9, Edinburgh Postnatal Depression Scale and Hospital Anxiety and Depression – Depression subscale scores by administration mode: An individual participant data differential item functioning meta-analysis
Issued Date
2024-09-15
Resource Type
ISSN
01650327
eISSN
15732517
Scopus ID
2-s2.0-85197374254
Pubmed ID
38908554
Journal Title
Journal of Affective Disorders
Volume
361
Start Page
674
End Page
683
Rights Holder(s)
SCOPUS
Bibliographic Citation
Journal of Affective Disorders Vol.361 (2024) , 674-683
Suggested Citation
Harel D., Wu Y., Levis B., Fan S., Sun Y., Xu M., Rice D.B., Boruff J., Markham S., Ioannidis J.P.A., Takwoingi Y., Patten S.B., Ziegelstein R.C., Cuijpers P., Gilbody S., Vigod S., Akena D., Benedetti A., Thombs B.D., Azar M., Bhandari P.M., Chiovitti M.J., He C., Imran M., Krishnan A., Negeri Z., Neupane D., Riehm K.E., Yan X.W., Kloda L.A., Henry M., Ismail Z., Loiselle C.G., Mitchell N.D., Al-Adawi S., Alvarado R., Amtmann D., Arroll B., Ayalon L., Baradaran H.R., Barnes J., Beck K.R., Beck C.T., Bernstein C.N., Bindt C., Bombardier C.H., Boye B., Büel-Drabe N., Buji R.I., Bunevicius A., Butterworth P., Can C., Carter G., Chagas M.H., Chan J.C.N., Chan L.F., Chen C.K., Chibanda D., Chorwe-Sungani G., Clover K., Conroy R.M., Conway A., Conwell Y., Correa H., Couto T.C.e., Cukor D., Daray F.M., de Man-van Ginkel J.M., De Souza J., Downing M.G., Eapen V., Fann J.R., Favez N., Felice E., Fellmeth G., Ferentinos P.P., Fernandes M., Field S., Figueiredo B., Fischer F.H., Fisher J.R.W., Flint A.J., Fujimori M., Fung D.S.S., Gallagher P., Gandy M., Gelaye B., Gholizadeh L., Gibson L.J., Goodyear-Smith F., Grassi L., Green E.P., Greeno C.G., Hall B.J., Hantsoo L., Haroz E.E., Härter M., Hegerl U., Helle N., Hernando A. Comparison of Patient Health Questionnaire-9, Edinburgh Postnatal Depression Scale and Hospital Anxiety and Depression – Depression subscale scores by administration mode: An individual participant data differential item functioning meta-analysis. Journal of Affective Disorders Vol.361 (2024) , 674-683. 683. doi:10.1016/j.jad.2024.06.033 Retrieved from: https://repository.li.mahidol.ac.th/handle/20.500.14594/99610
Title
Comparison of Patient Health Questionnaire-9, Edinburgh Postnatal Depression Scale and Hospital Anxiety and Depression – Depression subscale scores by administration mode: An individual participant data differential item functioning meta-analysis
Author(s)
Harel D.
Wu Y.
Levis B.
Fan S.
Sun Y.
Xu M.
Rice D.B.
Boruff J.
Markham S.
Ioannidis J.P.A.
Takwoingi Y.
Patten S.B.
Ziegelstein R.C.
Cuijpers P.
Gilbody S.
Vigod S.
Akena D.
Benedetti A.
Thombs B.D.
Azar M.
Bhandari P.M.
Chiovitti M.J.
He C.
Imran M.
Krishnan A.
Negeri Z.
Neupane D.
Riehm K.E.
Yan X.W.
Kloda L.A.
Henry M.
Ismail Z.
Loiselle C.G.
Mitchell N.D.
Al-Adawi S.
Alvarado R.
Amtmann D.
Arroll B.
Ayalon L.
Baradaran H.R.
Barnes J.
Beck K.R.
Beck C.T.
Bernstein C.N.
Bindt C.
Bombardier C.H.
Boye B.
Büel-Drabe N.
Buji R.I.
Bunevicius A.
Butterworth P.
Can C.
Carter G.
Chagas M.H.
Chan J.C.N.
Chan L.F.
Chen C.K.
Chibanda D.
Chorwe-Sungani G.
Clover K.
Conroy R.M.
Conway A.
Conwell Y.
Correa H.
Couto T.C.e.
Cukor D.
Daray F.M.
de Man-van Ginkel J.M.
De Souza J.
Downing M.G.
Eapen V.
Fann J.R.
Favez N.
Felice E.
Fellmeth G.
Ferentinos P.P.
Fernandes M.
Field S.
Figueiredo B.
Fischer F.H.
Fisher J.R.W.
Flint A.J.
Fujimori M.
Fung D.S.S.
Gallagher P.
Gandy M.
Gelaye B.
Gholizadeh L.
Gibson L.J.
Goodyear-Smith F.
Grassi L.
Green E.P.
Greeno C.G.
Hall B.J.
Hantsoo L.
Haroz E.E.
Härter M.
Hegerl U.
Helle N.
Hernando A.
Wu Y.
Levis B.
Fan S.
Sun Y.
Xu M.
Rice D.B.
Boruff J.
Markham S.
Ioannidis J.P.A.
Takwoingi Y.
Patten S.B.
Ziegelstein R.C.
Cuijpers P.
Gilbody S.
Vigod S.
Akena D.
Benedetti A.
Thombs B.D.
Azar M.
Bhandari P.M.
Chiovitti M.J.
He C.
Imran M.
Krishnan A.
Negeri Z.
Neupane D.
Riehm K.E.
Yan X.W.
Kloda L.A.
Henry M.
Ismail Z.
Loiselle C.G.
Mitchell N.D.
Al-Adawi S.
Alvarado R.
Amtmann D.
Arroll B.
Ayalon L.
Baradaran H.R.
Barnes J.
Beck K.R.
Beck C.T.
Bernstein C.N.
Bindt C.
Bombardier C.H.
Boye B.
Büel-Drabe N.
Buji R.I.
Bunevicius A.
Butterworth P.
Can C.
Carter G.
Chagas M.H.
Chan J.C.N.
Chan L.F.
Chen C.K.
Chibanda D.
Chorwe-Sungani G.
Clover K.
Conroy R.M.
Conway A.
Conwell Y.
Correa H.
Couto T.C.e.
Cukor D.
Daray F.M.
de Man-van Ginkel J.M.
De Souza J.
Downing M.G.
Eapen V.
Fann J.R.
Favez N.
Felice E.
Fellmeth G.
Ferentinos P.P.
Fernandes M.
Field S.
Figueiredo B.
Fischer F.H.
Fisher J.R.W.
Flint A.J.
Fujimori M.
Fung D.S.S.
Gallagher P.
Gandy M.
Gelaye B.
Gholizadeh L.
Gibson L.J.
Goodyear-Smith F.
Grassi L.
Green E.P.
Greeno C.G.
Hall B.J.
Hantsoo L.
Haroz E.E.
Härter M.
Hegerl U.
Helle N.
Hernando A.
Author's Affiliation
Kamuzu University of Health Sciences
Instituto de Investigación Hospital 12 de Octubre
Makerere University College of Health Sciences
Hotchkiss Brain Institute
O'Brien Institute for Public Health
School of Medicine
School of Medicine and Public Health
Berliner Institut für Gesundheitsforschung
Lietuvos Sveikatos Mokslų Universitetas
NYU Shanghai
Oslo Universitetssykehus
Birmingham and Solihull Mental Health NHS Foundation Trust
ANU Medical School
Chang Gung University College of Medicine
L-Università ta' Malta
Sultan Qaboos University College of Medicine and Health Sciences
University of Zimbabwe
University of London
Harvard T.H. Chan School of Public Health
McMaster University
London School of Hygiene & Tropical Medicine
University of Alberta
Universidade Federal de Minas Gerais
McGill Faculty of Medicine and Health Sciences
National and Kapodistrian University of Athens
University of Washington School of Medicine
UNSW Sydney
Dublin City University
Iran University of Medical Sciences
Prince of Wales Hospital Hong Kong
University of Rochester Medical Center
University of Ferrara
University of Technology Sydney
MRC Lifecourse Epidemiology Unit
National Cancer Center Japan
Institut Lady Davis de Recherches Médicales
New York University
Universidade do Minho
University of Birmingham
UniversitatsSpital Zurich
Monash University
Macquarie University
Singapore General Hospital
University of Newcastle, College of Health, Medicine and Wellbeing
Women's College Hospital
University of York
Leids Universitair Medisch Centrum
University of Pittsburgh
Universidade Federal de Uberlândia
University Health Network
University of Waterloo
Faculty of Medicine, Nursing and Health Sciences
King's College London
Queensland University of Technology
Rogosin Institute
Stanford Law School
St. Joseph's Healthcare Hamilton
University of Manitoba
Singapore Institute of Mental Health
Universidad de Valparaiso
Vrije Universiteit Amsterdam
School of Nursing
Universidade de São Paulo
Goethe-Universität Frankfurt am Main
Centre Universitaire de Santé McGill
Johns Hopkins Bloomberg School of Public Health
The University of Auckland
Duke University School of Medicine
Universitätsklinikum Hamburg-Eppendorf
Université de Genève
Bar-Ilan University
University of Oxford Medical Sciences Division
Université McGill
Universiti Kebangsaan Malaysia
Universidad de Buenos Aires
Johns Hopkins University School of Medicine
Cumming School of Medicine
University of Cape Town
Royal College of Surgeons in Ireland
Hospital Mesra Bukit Padang
Adana City Training and Research Hospital
Instituto de Investigación Hospital 12 de Octubre
Makerere University College of Health Sciences
Hotchkiss Brain Institute
O'Brien Institute for Public Health
School of Medicine
School of Medicine and Public Health
Berliner Institut für Gesundheitsforschung
Lietuvos Sveikatos Mokslų Universitetas
NYU Shanghai
Oslo Universitetssykehus
Birmingham and Solihull Mental Health NHS Foundation Trust
ANU Medical School
Chang Gung University College of Medicine
L-Università ta' Malta
Sultan Qaboos University College of Medicine and Health Sciences
University of Zimbabwe
University of London
Harvard T.H. Chan School of Public Health
McMaster University
London School of Hygiene & Tropical Medicine
University of Alberta
Universidade Federal de Minas Gerais
McGill Faculty of Medicine and Health Sciences
National and Kapodistrian University of Athens
University of Washington School of Medicine
UNSW Sydney
Dublin City University
Iran University of Medical Sciences
Prince of Wales Hospital Hong Kong
University of Rochester Medical Center
University of Ferrara
University of Technology Sydney
MRC Lifecourse Epidemiology Unit
National Cancer Center Japan
Institut Lady Davis de Recherches Médicales
New York University
Universidade do Minho
University of Birmingham
UniversitatsSpital Zurich
Monash University
Macquarie University
Singapore General Hospital
University of Newcastle, College of Health, Medicine and Wellbeing
Women's College Hospital
University of York
Leids Universitair Medisch Centrum
University of Pittsburgh
Universidade Federal de Uberlândia
University Health Network
University of Waterloo
Faculty of Medicine, Nursing and Health Sciences
King's College London
Queensland University of Technology
Rogosin Institute
Stanford Law School
St. Joseph's Healthcare Hamilton
University of Manitoba
Singapore Institute of Mental Health
Universidad de Valparaiso
Vrije Universiteit Amsterdam
School of Nursing
Universidade de São Paulo
Goethe-Universität Frankfurt am Main
Centre Universitaire de Santé McGill
Johns Hopkins Bloomberg School of Public Health
The University of Auckland
Duke University School of Medicine
Universitätsklinikum Hamburg-Eppendorf
Université de Genève
Bar-Ilan University
University of Oxford Medical Sciences Division
Université McGill
Universiti Kebangsaan Malaysia
Universidad de Buenos Aires
Johns Hopkins University School of Medicine
Cumming School of Medicine
University of Cape Town
Royal College of Surgeons in Ireland
Hospital Mesra Bukit Padang
Adana City Training and Research Hospital
Corresponding Author(s)
Other Contributor(s)
Abstract
Administration mode of patient-reported outcome measures (PROMs) may influence responses. We assessed if Patient Health Questionnaire-9 (PHQ-9), Edinburgh Postnatal Depression Scale (EPDS) and Hospital Anxiety and Depression Scale – Depression subscale (HADS-D) item responses and scores were associated with administration mode. We compared (1) self-administration versus interview-administration; within self-administration (2) research or medical setting versus private; and (3) pen-and-paper versus electronic; and within interview-administration (4) in-person versus phone. We analysed individual participant data meta-analysis datasets with item-level data for the PHQ-9 (N = 34,529), EPDS (N = 16,813), and HADS-D (N = 16,768). We used multiple indicator multiple cause models to assess differential item functioning (DIF) by administration mode. We found statistically significant DIF for most items on all measures due to large samples, but influence on total scores was negligible. In 10 comparisons conducted across the PHQ-9, EPDS, and HADS-D, Pearson's correlations and intraclass correlation coefficients between latent depression symptom scores from models that did or did not account for DIF were between 0.995 and 1.000. Total PHQ-9, EPDS, and HADS-D scores did not differ materially across administration modes. Researcher and clinicians who evaluate depression symptoms with these questionnaires can select administration methods based on patient preferences, feasibility, or cost.